Reactions to “I’ve Failed” — Good Intentions

Reactions to “I’ve Failed”

I contributed to a discussion on the Photography Daily podcast about Failure. Neale James posted a recording of his conversation with Sean Tucker, relating a text conversation he had with his friend who felt that he had failed as a photographer. Neale asked Sean what he thought of his friend’s sentiment. Sean’s position was that we take ownership of the things that we can control and let go of everything else that affect us but are outside our sphere of influence or control. This school of philosophy is called Stoicsm. It is similar to what I’ve been reading and thinking about but I’ve not realised it is part of wider framework of thinking.

Being prepared can sometimes appear as luck

The reverse approach of stoicism is berating and faulting ourselves for failing to change something we have absolutely no control over (e.g. Other people’s expectation of how we should behave). Approaching this issue from a slightly different perspective, I reflected about how perceptions of failure are viewed from an Asian family’s point of view.

Growing up with an Asian Catholic background, martyrdom in the face of avoidable agony is deemed a virtue. It is almost expected. If we’re not suffering for our family, we’re not filial or “good”. Generally, someone has to suffer in order for the family to save face and feel pride. The concept of win-win is quite foreign.


“Community before the individual, family before self and duty before passion. ”


While it might be easy to paint such behaviour as evil and harmful, the reality is that the roots of such behaviour is planted in more benign origins. At school, we are taught in our Moral Education classes (yup, Singapore students from my generation study about morals) that we need to be kind to others, filial to our parents and do our civic duties (i.e don’t litter). As crazy as it sounds, I would not have it any other way. In our current world we live in, a little more “You” and la lot less “Me” will help make the world a nice place. The problem, as with anything else (e.g religion), is when we go to the extreme. More often than not, too much of a good thing does not end up being good.

As a Singapore who ran away from “home”, I’m struggling to find the balance between my eastern and western philosophies. How do I look after myself well enough so that I can look after my family and friends in a way that I do not get lost in self-centredness or find myself chained to causes that have no logical way of resolution?